Initial Decisions are issued by an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) following an evidentiary hearing. Both parties may appeal an Initial Decision to the State Personnel Board. Upon review, the Board may adopt the findings of fact and conclusions of law in the Initial Decision; the Board may adopt the findings of fact in the Initial Decision but reverse on one or more conclusions of law; or the Board may reverse the Initial Decision's findings of fact and conclusions of law. If neither party appeals an Initial Decision, it is considered the final order of the Board.
This page compiles Initial Decisions issued by Administrative Law Judges, provided in the PDF file format. Beginning with Fiscal Year 2015-16, all Initial Decisions issued within that fiscal year are listed. Prior decisions are listed by the year assigned in the case number (e.g. "2014G000"), not the year in which the Initial Decision was actually issued.
Note that the Board Rules and governing statutes change from time to time. In addition, the Colorado Supreme Court and the Colorado Court of Appeals both issue decisions that control subsequent Initial Decisions. Moreover, the Board may reverse an Initial Decision's conclusions of law. Therefore, you should carefully research whether any Initial Decision that you rely upon continues to have any persuasive value.
Record of Initial Decisions
Fiscal Years:
2024-25 | 2023-24 | 2022-23 | 2021-22 | 2020-21 | 2019-20 | 2018-19 | 2017-18 | 2016-17 | 2015-16 | 2014-15 | 2013-14 | 2012-13 | 2011-12 | 2010-11 | 2009-10 | 2008-09 | 2007-08 | 2006-07
FY 2024-25| Initial Decision Number | Case Name and Date | Claims/Issues Analyzed in the Initial Decision |
|---|
| 2024B079 | LaTosha Turner v. DOL (3/26/25) | Arbitrary or capricious; discipline contrary to rule or law. |
| 2025B011 | Reed v. DHS (3/3/25) | Arbitrary or capricious; discipline contrary to rule or law; Whistleblower Act. |
| 2024B091 | Ryan v. DPA (1/30/25) | Whistleblower Act. |
| 2025B022 | Schlagel v. Mines (1/21/25) | Job abandonment. |
| 2024S051 | Roberts v. DPA (1/6/25) | Age discrimination under CADA. |
| 2025B004 | Priest v. DHS (1/6/25) | Arbitrary or capricious; discipline contrary to rule or law. |
| 2024B078 | Waldrop v. DHS (11/4/24) | Arbitrary or capricious; discipline contrary to rule or law. |
| 2024B087 | Clare v. DOC (10/21/24) | Arbitrary or capricious; discipline contrary to rule or law. |
| 2024G083 | Vigil v. DOC (9/27/24) | Arbitrary or capricious; reduction of monthly salary to correct an error. |
| 2024G077 | Segura v. DOC (9/27/24) | Arbitrary or capricious; reduction of monthly salary to correct an error; Whistleblower Act. |
| 2024G095 | Lung v. CSU (9/23/24) | Arbitrary or capricious; reduction of monthly salary to correct an error. |
| 2024G076 | Cutts v. DOC (8/2/24) | Arbitrary or capricious. |
Back to Top
FY 2023-24| Initial Decision Number | Case Name and Date | Claims/Issues Analyzed in the Initial Decision |
|---|
| 2024S019 | Bataille v. DPS (6/17/24) | Race discrimination under CADA; after-acquired evidence. |
| 2024B028 | Behnam v. DOC (6/17/24) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline; discipline contrary to rule or law; national origin/ancestry discrimination under CADA: Whistleblower Act. |
| 2023B067 | Hofacker v. DPS (5/2/24) | Appeal of administrative separation. |
| 2024S008 | Mayes v. DHS (4/29/24) | Race and sex discrimination under CADA; attorney fees. |
| 2024B019 | Quinones-Colon v. AHEC (2/28/24) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline; discipline contrary to rule or law; attorney fees. |
| 2024B002 | Gonzales v. DOC (11/20/23) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline; discipline contrary to rule or law. |
| 2023B052 | Rath v. DPS (11/14/23) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline; discipline contrary to rule or law; disability discrimination under CADA. |
| 2023B023 | Mendias v. DHS (9/28/23) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline; discipline contrary to rule or law; Whistleblower Act. |
| 2023G013 | Little v. DOC (8/30/23) | Retaliation under CADA; Whistleblower Act |
| 2022B060 | Fernandez v. DPS (6/6/23) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline; discipline contrary to rule or law; religious discrimination under CADA. |
Back to Top
FY 2022-23| Initial Decision Number | Case Name and Date | Claims/Issues Analyzed in the Initial Decision |
|---|
| 2023B043 | Robinson v. DHS (6/7/23) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline; discipline contrary to rule or law. |
| 2023B016 | Medina v. DOC (2/21/23) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline; discipline contrary to rule or law; attorney fees. |
| 2022G020 | Martin v. OIT (1/23/23) | Discrimination and retaliation under CADA; attorney fees. |
| 2022S021 | Nocera v. DORA (12/28/22) | Age discrimination; attorney fees. |
| 2014B061 | McCauley v. DOR (7/21/22) | Contrary to rule or law; attorney fees. |
| 2022B035 | Miller v. DOC (7/1/22) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline; discipline contrary to rule or law; burden of proof; attorney fees. |
| 2022B045 | Selman v. DHS (4/1/22) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline; discipline contrary to rule or law; burden of proof. |
| 2021B022 | Hidalgo v. DHS (3/1/22) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline; burden of proof; attorney fees. |
Back to Top
FY 2021-22| Initial Decision Number | Case Name and Date | Claims/Issues Analyzed in the Initial Decision |
|---|
| 2022B043 | Foust v. DOC (4/4/22) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline; sex discrimination under CADA. |
| 2022B037 | McGahan v. DOC (2/24/22) | Appeal of administrative separation. |
| 2022B008 | Spaid v. CDOT (3/3/22) | Associational discrimination under CADA; attorney fees. |
| 2022B013 | Bernabei v. DOC (1/21/22) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline; discipline contrary to rule or law; disability discrimination under CADA. |
| 2016B034 | Stiles v. DOC (11/30/21) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline; discipline contrary to rule or law; damages. |
| 2021G043 | Maes v. CDOT (11/29/21) | Retaliation under CADA; Whistleblower Act. |
| 2021B054 | Martinez v. DHS (9/7/21) | Appeal of administrative separation; disability discrimination. |
| 2021B031 | Kim v. DPS (7/6/21) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline; discipline contrary to rule or law; race discrimination; retaliation under CADA; Whistleblower Act. |
Back to Top
FY 2020-21| Initial Decision Number | Case Name and Date | Claims/Issues Analyzed in the Initial Decision |
|---|
| 2019G061 | Fisher v. FRCC (4/29/21) | Age discrimination; attorney fees. |
| 2021B040 | Greene v. UCB (4/21/21) | PERA benefits. |
| 2021B022 | Hidalgo v. DHS (3/1/21) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline; attorney fees. |
| 2020B062(c) | Greco v. UCB (2/19/21) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline; appeal of administrative separation; disability discrimination; retaliation under CADA; Whistleblower Act. |
| 2019B023(c) | Pace v. DHS (1/25/21) | Disability discrimination; retaliation under CADA; administrative leave; attorney fees. |
| 2019G031(c) | Salloum v. CDOT (12/21/20) | Retaliation under CADA; comparative analysis. |
| 2020B046(c) | Cappello v. DHS (11/23/20) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law. |
| 2020B053 | Scholl v. DOC (10/25/20) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law. |
| 2020B036 | Nunez v. DHS (10/5/20). | Race discrimination; constructive discharge. |
| 2020B016 | Vincze v. DOR (10/2/20). | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law. |
| 2020B047 | Kim v. DPS (9/28/20). | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, attorney fees. |
| 2020G009 | Gregg v. DOR (9/21/20). | Retaliation under CADA; Whistleblower Act. |
| 2020B060 | Roberts v. DOC (9/21/20). | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, attorney fees. |
| 2019G075(c) | Ward v. DOC (9/21/20). | Retaliation under CADA. |
| 2020B057 | Pacheco v. DOC (9/15/20). | Appeal of administrative separation; disability discrimination; Order Granting Summary Judgment. |
| 2019B094 | Liljekvist v. UCCS (8/21/20). | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2020B052 | Barahona v. DHS (8/12/20). | Arbitrary or capricious discipline |
Back to Top
FY 2019-20| Initial Decision Number | Case Name and Date | Claims/Issues Analyzed in the Initial Decision |
|---|
| 2020G045 | Dublinski v. UCB (6/25/20) | Board's jurisdiction (whether alleged suspension constitutes a disciplinary action). |
| 2018B056(c) | Anderson v. DHS (7/1/19) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, race discrimination, remedies, attorney fees. |
Back to Top
FY 2018-19| Initial Decision Number | Case Name and Date | Claims/Issues Analyzed in the Initial Decision |
|---|
| 2019B034 | Copley v. DOC (6/10/19) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law. |
| 2019B038 | Wright v. CDLE (5/21/19) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, notice of dismissal. |
| 2018B012 | Muller v. DOC (12/31/18) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, retaliation under CADA, Whistleblower Act. |
| 2018B079 | Cleveland v. DOR (11/13/18) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, attorney fees. |
| 2019B002 | Farago v. DOC (11/9/18). | Order Determining Question of Law, administrative discharge for exhaustion of leave. |
| 2018S015 | Baumgardner v. CDOT (9/25/18) | Sex discrimination. |
| 2018B019 | Ricci v. DMVA (7/13/18) | Sex discrimination, Whistleblower Act, attorney fees. |
Back to Top
FY 2017-18| Initial Decision Number | Case Name and Date | Claims/Issues Analyzed in the Initial Decision |
|---|
| 2017B045 | Pickering v. DPS (9/5/2017) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2016B075 | Saurini v. DOC (9/25/17) | Arbitrary or capricious administrative separation, appeal of Administrative Separation, Whistleblower Act. |
| 2017B016 | Armstrong v. DHS (10/2/17) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2016B021 | Macias v. UNC (11/9/17) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, age discrimination, disability discrimination, race discrimination, Whistleblower Act, attorney fees. |
| 2016B036 | Labazetta v. DOC (12/28/17) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, race and national origin discrimination, attorney fees. |
| 2018B004 | Dodson v. UCB (1/19/18) | Suspension pending disposition of a felony charge. |
| 2017B053 | Helmick v. CDOT (1/31/18) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, disability discrimination, failure to accommodate disability, harassment under CADA, attorney fees. |
| 2017B070 | Yu v. DPS (2/22/18) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, disability discrimination. |
| 2016G011(C) | Bloem v. HCPF (3/9/18) | Discipline contrary to rule or law, disability discrimination, retaliation under CADA, attorney fees. |
| 2017B078 | Singleton v. DOC (3/29/18) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, attorney fees. |
Back to Top
FY 2016-17| Initial Decision Number | Case Name and Date | Claims/Issues Analyzed in the Initial Decision |
|---|
| 2016B029 | Lorenzo v. DHS (10/17/16) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline as a result of criminal charge, attorney fees. |
| 2015B045 | Garcia v. DOL (8/5/16) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, attorney fees. |
| 2016B069 | Rome v. UCCS (8/10/16) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2015G061 | Whitney v. DHS (8/22/16) | Whistleblower Act. |
| 2016B013 | Rodgers v. MSU (12/12/16) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, attorney fees. |
| 2017B001 | Emerson v. DPS (12/19/16) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2016B083 | Baca v. DHS (1/11/17) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, attorney fees. |
| 2016B087(C) | Scherbarth v. DOC (3/6/17) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, attorney fees. |
| 2016B058 | Rushing v. DHS (12/16/16) | Discipline contrary to rule or law, attorney fees. |
| 2016G006(C) | Saldana v. DHS (6/29/17) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, Whistleblower Act, attorney fees. |
Back to Top
FY 2015-16| Initial Decision Number | Case Name and Date | Claims/Issues Analyzed in the Initial Decision |
|---|
| 2015B011(c) | Chavez v. DOE (7/23/15) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, attorney fees. |
| 2015B067 | Schreffler v.DOR (8/11/15) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, disability discrimination, sex discrimination, Whistleblower Act, attorney fees. |
| 2014G013 | Starling v. DOR (8/31/15) | Sex discrimination, attorney fees. |
| 2015B044 | Martinez v. DOC (9/9/15) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2015B092 | Martinez v. DOC (12/4/15) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2016B002 | Carlis v. DHS (12/16/15) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law. |
| 2014B118 | Garrett v. DOC (1/11/16) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, attorney fees. |
| 2015B003 | Jimerson v. DOC (1/11/16) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, attorney fees. |
| 2016B007 | Sturtevant v. DOC (1/29/16) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, attorney fees. |
| 2015B108 | Goldman v. CDOT (3/4/16) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, Whistleblower Act, attorney fees. |
| 2015B089 | Cordova v. DHS (3/14/16) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, attorney fees. |
| 2015G091(c) | Michel v. CDOT (6/24/16) | Age discrimination, attorney fees. |
Back to Top
FY 2014-15| Initial Decision Number | Case Name and Date | Claims/Issues Analyzed in the Initial Decision |
|---|
| 2014B003 | Sullivan v. CDOT (3/17/14) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, disability discrimination, interactive process, attorney fees, remedies. |
| 2014B019 | Smith v. CSU (5/27/14) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, attorney fees. |
| 2014B033 | Sheridan v. DOC (7/7/14) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2014B034 | Chen v. DHS (10/2/14) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2014B120 | Hageman v. DOC (Order Granting Summary Judgment) (1/22/15) | Disability discrimination, appeal of Administrative Separation. |
| 2014B049 | York v. DHS (1/29/15) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, race discrimination. |
| 2014B097 | Turner v. DOR (3/13/15) | Disability discrimination, interactive process, appeal of Administrative Separation, remedies. |
| 2015B022 | Boston v. DHS (6/26/15) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, attorney fees. |
Back to Top
FY 2013-14| Initial Decision Number | Case Name and Date | Claims/Issues Analyzed in the Initial Decision |
|---|
| 2013B003 | Biddle v. DPA (11/2/12) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, attorney fees. |
| 2013B004 | Homann v. DPS (3/22/13) | Transfers of positions within state system, status in the personnel system. |
| 2013B006 | Blume v. DPS (2/21/13) | Board's jurisdiction over non-classified state employee. |
| 2013B026 | Chosvig v. DOR (8/16/13) | Disability discrimination, failure to accommodate disability, appeal of Administrative Separation, attorney fees. |
| 2013B029 | Geremaia v. CDOT (2/4/13) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, attorney fees. |
| 2013B046 | Firko v. DPS (3/6/13) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law. |
| 2013B049 | Rich v. DOR (6/27/13) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, Whistleblower Act. |
| 2013B068(C) | Paiz v. DHS (4/23/13) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, attorney fees. |
| 2013B076(C) | Ksouri v. OIT (2/26/14) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, disability discrimination, national origin discrimination, harassment under CADA, retaliation under CADA, attorney fees. |
| 2013B092(C) | Wanker v. Gallegos v. CDOT (12/27/13) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, attorney fees. |
| 2013B113 | Montoya v. CDPHE (1/30/14) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law. |
| 2013B116 | Mitchell v. UCB (9/9/13) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2013B120 | Larsen v. DOA (8/29/13) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2013B129 | Neumeister v. DOC (11/14/13) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2013B142(C) | Reno v. DHS (8/28/14) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, appeal of Administrative Separation, Whistleblower Act. |
| 2013G080 | Hardesty v. DHS (5/12/14) | Retaliation under CADA, Whistleblower Act. |
| 2013S031 | Harrison v. DHS (4/25/14) | Age discrimination. |
Back to Top
FY 2012-13| Initial Decision Number | Case Name and Date | Claims/Issues Analyzed in the Initial Decision |
|---|
| 2012B004 | Skitt v. UCB (7/19/12) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2012B013(C) | Johnson v. CDOT (3/13/12) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2012B016 | Buckley v. FRCC (3/23/12) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2012B018 | Crouse v. DPS (4/18/12) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2012B036 | Hilario v. UCB (5/14/12) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, attorney fees. |
| 2012B045 | Hegler v. DHS (4/23/12) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, attorney fees. |
| 2012B055 | Lawson v. DOC (4/24/12) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2012B071 | Bell v. MSCD (6/12/12) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, attorney fees. |
| 2012B108 | Arellano v. DOR (11/5/12) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, attorney fees. |
| 2012B123A | Wunderlich v. DHS (11/20/12) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, attorney fees. |
| 2012B128 | Brown v. DHS (9/13/13) | Disability discrimination. |
| 2012B131 | Robinson v. UCD (1/28/13) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, age discrimination, race discrimination, Whistleblower Act. |
Back to Top
FY 2011-12| Initial Decision Number | Case Name and Date | Claims/Issues Analyzed in the Initial Decision |
|---|
| 2011B001 | Cruz v. DHS (4/21/11) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, attorney fees. |
| 2011B017 | Lease v. DHS (2/16/11) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2011B033 | Apodaca v. DOR (3/14/11) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, attorney fees. |
| 2011B039 | Rushing v. DPS (5/4/11) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2011B042 | Lewthwaite v. UCD (5/16/11) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, Whistleblower Act. |
| 2011B063 | Robinson v. UCD (9/26/11) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, retaliation under CADA, Whistleblower Act. |
| 2011B066 | Gietl v. DPS (8/1/11) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, reverse gender discrimination, attorney fees. |
| 2011B086 | Foxworth v. DHS (1/11/13) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, age discrimination, race discrimination. |
| 2011B100 | Riley v. DOC (7/12/12) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law. |
| 2011G028 | Williams v. DPS (7/16/12) | Sexual orientation discrimination, attorney fees. |
| 2011G028(2) | Williams v. DPS (8/29/13) | Calculation of damages. |
| 2011G099 | Rounds v. DHS (2/21/13) | Retaliation under CADA, attorney fees. |
Back to Top
FY 2010-11| Initial Decision Number | Case Name and Date | Claims/Issues Analyzed in the Initial Decision |
|---|
| 2010B015 | Redding v. DNR (4/27/10) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, Whistleblower Act, attorney fees. |
| 2010B027 | Vidor v. DNR (6/21/10) | Discipline contrary to rule or law, age discrimination, national origin discrimination, Whistleblower Act, attorney fees. |
| 2010B049(C) | Romero v. UCB (9/30/10) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, national origin discrimination, retaliation under CADA. |
| 2010B065 | Harris v. CSU (5/21/10) | Arbitrary or capricious reorganization resulting in reduction from full-time to part-time. |
| 2010B067 | McCauley v. UCD (4/21/10) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2010B087(C) | Beruman & Adams v. DHS (9/23/10) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law. |
| 2010B097 | Lyons v. DHS (6/22/11) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, race discrimination. |
| 2010B101 | Griffith v. Mines (7/19/10) | Arbitrary or capricious termination, appeal of Administrative Separation. |
| 2010B107 | Leyba v. DOC (1/13/11) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law. |
| 2010B117 | Lopez v. CDOT (11/4/10) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2010B127 | Riley v. DHS (9/9/10) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2010G005 | Katzenmeyer v. DOC (11/15/10) | Whistleblower Act. |
| 2010G040(c) | Luchenburg v. CDLE & OIT (3/4/11) | Gender discrimination, harassment under CADA, retaliation under CADA, attorney fees. |
| 2010G082 | Schutte v. DOC (12/16/11) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, religious discrimination, harassment under CADA, retaliation under CADA. |
| 2010G087 | Livesay v. CDOT (5/20/11) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
Back to Top
FY 2009-10| Initial Decision Number | Case Name and Date | Claims/Issues Analyzed in the Initial Decision |
|---|
| 2009B004 | Lujan v. DHS (1/13/09) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law. |
| 2009B012 | Bryant v. UC Medical (10/5/09) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, race discrimination, attorney fees. |
| 2009B016(C) | Wilday-O'Neill v. DHS (4/9/09) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, Whistleblower Act. |
| 2009B018 | Gonser v. CDOT (1/12/09) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, pre-judgment interest, attorney fees. |
| 2009B021 | Vigil v. DOC (2/20/09) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2009B030 | Harp v. DHS (6/22/09) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, race discrimination. |
| 2009B036 | Diallo v. DHS (4/8/09) | Appeal of Administrative Separation. |
| 2009B038 | Umstead v. DPS (6/3/09) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2009B043 | Smith v. DOC (7/30/09) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2009B082(C) | Shaw & Zarlingo v. DHS (9/10/09) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2009B094 | Trujillo v. DOC (11/18/10) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, disability discrimination. |
| 2009G006 | Nawrocki v. DPS (3/6/09) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, retaliation. |
| 2009G018 | DePaul v. DHS (4/20/09) | Appeal of constructive discharge. |
| 2009G085 | Miller v. DPS (8/23/10) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, attorney fees. |
Back to Top
FY 2008-09| Initial Decision Number | Case Name and Date | Claims/Issues Analyzed in the Initial Decision |
|---|
| 2008B009 | Branch v. DPS (11/26/07) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2008B013 | Olson v. DOLA (4/10/08) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, Senior Executive Service employee, violation of constitution, age discrimination. |
| 2008B018 | Doering v. DNR (12/28/07) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, attorney fees. |
| 2008B029 | Bustamante v. UCB (2/27/08) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law. |
| 2008B032 | Benson v. DOC (2/27/08) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, offense of mortal turpitude, attorney fees. |
| 2008B033 | Carver v. DOR (4/7/08) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2008B038 | Bushrow v. CDOT (3/13/08) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2008B040 | Gilbert v. Mines (8/20/09) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, disability discrimination. |
| 2008B050 | Harris v. DHS (5/23/08) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2008B081 | Salazar v. DOR (6/29/09) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discrimination, attorney fees. |
| 2008B093 | Houston v. DOC (12/29/08) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, attorney fees. |
| 2008B095 | Jones v. DOC (10/2/08) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2008B106 | Rodriguez v. UCD (1/9/09) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2008G090 | Barwick v. DOC (1/22/09) | Probationary employee, violation of statute. |
| 2008S010 | Wilson v. UCCS (10/16/09) | Age discrimination, remedy, attorney fees. |
Back to Top
FY 2007-08| Initial Decision Number | Case Name and Date | Claims/Issues Analyzed in the Initial Decision |
|---|
| 2007B005 | Nuss v. DPS (3/30/07) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2007B009 | Catholic v. DHS (3/7/07) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2007B015(C) | Romero v. UCB (2/19/08) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law. |
| 2007B030 | MacDonald v. CDOT (3/16/07) | Discipline contrary to rule or law, Whistleblower Act, breach of settlement agreement. |
| 2007B032 | Mares v. Ft. Lewis College (5/15/07) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law. |
| 2007B047 | Messinger v. DOC (6/14/07) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2007B070 | Grasmick v. DOC (7/19/07) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2007B071 | Horak v. DNR (10/18/07) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2007B073(C) | Maynard v. HCPF (12/8/08) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, sex discrimination, race discrimination, retaliation under CADA, Whistleblower Act, remedy, attorney fees. |
| 2007B075 | Martinez v. DHS (1/25/08) | Age discrimination, disability discrimination, race discrimination, appeal of Administrative Separation. |
| 2007B076 | Baughman v. CSU (10/4/07) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2007B090 | Smith v. DHS (12/7/07) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, age discrimination, disability discrimination. |
| 2007B094 | Autenreith v. CDLE (10/10/07) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2007B097 | Nawrocki v. DPS (10/4/07) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2007B098 | Gonser v. CDOT (9/4/07) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2007B102 | Malloy v. DHS (3/3/08) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, Whistleblower Act. |
| 2007G073 | Pridemore v. CDPHE (5/19/08) | Corrective action contrary to rule or law, jurisdiction, remedy. |
| 2007G089 | Kirkmeyer v. DOLA (1/14/10) | Senior Executive Service employee. |
| 2007G089(2) | Kirkmeyer v. DOLA (11/21/12) | Senior Executive Service employee, jurisdiction. |
Back to Top
FY 2006-07| Initial Decision Number | Case Name and Date | Claims/Issues Analyzed in the Initial Decision |
|---|
| 2006B007 | Robinson v. DHS (3/21/06) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2006B013 | Little v. DOC (5/25/06) | Appeal of resignation. |
| 2006B039 | Shea v. DHS (5/31/06) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, attorney fees. |
| 2006B040 | Sarek v. DOC (4/3/06) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, attorney fees. |
| 2006B046 | Quintana v. CDOT (12/12/06) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2006B051(C) | Donaldson v. DPS (5/16/07) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, age discrimination, disability discrimination, national origin discrimination, race discrimination. |
| 2006B053 | Salazar v. CSU (10/24/06) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, age discrimination, disability discrimination, remedy (medical expenses). |
| 2006B058 | Maggard v. DHS (10/23/06) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, attorney fees. |
| 2006B079 | Myers v. DPA (11/24/06) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law, remedy (medical expenses), secondary employment. |
| 2006B100 | Lybarger v. CSU (4/3/07) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2006B107 | Applegate v. DPA (11/2/06) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline. |
| 2006B109 | Sailas v. UC (11/30/06) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, criminal conviction. |
| 2006G046 | Clay v. DOC (1/18/07) | Sex discrimination. |
| 2006G047 | Hernandez v. DOR (9/27/06) | Race discrimination, national origin discrimination. |
| 2006G074 | Monett v. DOC (9/29/07) | Arbitrary or capricious discipline, discipline contrary to rule or law. |
Back to Top
